Monday, October 02, 2006

big nothing

it has been an exciting 24 hours in cubdom for some, dear reader.

first the team itself ended the 2006 campaign by avoiding its 97th loss -- but the damage, to say the least, had already been done. the 66-96 (.407) saga of this year is the worst cub season since 2000's 97-loss entry and becomes the second-worst year of the tribune era (behind only 2000).

subsequently to the conclusion of the game, team president andy macfail resigned, with marketing guru john mcdonough moving into the spot of interim team president.

MacPhail's departure had been in the making since midsummer. FitzSimons termed it "a baseball decision." The Cubs made great strides in generating revenue and modernizing Wrigley Field on MacPhail's watch but continued to flounder on the field, reaching the playoffs just twice.

MacPhail operated with a handshake agreement rather than a contract.

"It's time," he said. "The clock on the MacPhail-o-meter has run down to zero."

MacPhail said he met in July with Crane Kenney, Tribune Co. senior vice president and general counsel, for "an A-to-Z evaluation of the team" and offered his resignation.

"Obviously, this has been an awful season," MacPhail said. "I reminded Crane, 'Look, this relationship has to be one where both parties have to be satisfied that they're getting everything they need out of the other party, and if you need my resignation, you can have it when you want it.'"

Weeks later, MacPhail met with FitzSimons, who said, "Look, Andy, we've got to try something different."

MacPhail took responsibility for the Cubs' failure to field a consistent winner during his tenure.

"It's not just that we had a terrible season," he said. "I've been here 12 years, 12 seasons, and we've had only two postseasons. That's not what I came here to do. Obviously, I haven't been as effective as I wanted to be. It's pretty thin soup for a franchise that's had a payroll generally in the top four, or five or six or seven, over the course of that time.

"We should be doing better, and we're not. And I'm the CEO, and I'm responsible. I've been in the business my entire life, and there's one rule that applies to everything. You've got to win, and if you don't win, it's subject to change."


macfail's record in chicago ends as one of repeated disaster -- as has often been noted, his twelve years were notably worse on the field than the years that preceded them. that attendance has spiralled ever higher is a function of both the marketing genius of mcdonough and the economic and residential renaissance of wrigleyville over those years, but certainly nothing the team has done between the lines.

third, and least surprising, dusty baker will be dismissed as manager of the team later today.

Baker said he will leave with his head high, knowing he never backed down from his principles or let his critics change him into something he was not.

"I am what I am, and I am who I am," he said. "My dad taught me a long time ago, speak the truth and be yourself, with no regrets."


the dusty watch is ending after just 15 months. no new manager has yet been announced.

so much sound and fury -- but what does it signify?

sadly, dear reader, very little. placing the mastermind of "beer-and-ivy-and-who-cares-what-the-score-is" at the head of the team tells everyone everything they need to know about what tribco's priorities are and have always been -- now such a noncontroversial fact that the tribune itself will tell you so. enticing words from dennis fitzsimons or mcdonough mean nothing. this club is concerned about profitability, not winning; mcdonough's promotion is yet another in a long, long line of crystalline signs confirming the verity of that statement.

the hard truth is that the baseball operations of this franchise are a disaster from head to foot. with extremely little positive except ticket sales to talk about, nothing will be revolutionized in a day -- the scale of the troubles is simply far too great for quick fixes. the process of rehabilitating the chicago national league ballclub will take years, probably several years. dumping macfail and baker -- while certainly necessary -- is but a minor first step. the words spoken by fitzsimons and mcdonough are signal of nothing so much as their complete lack of understanding of just exactly how horrifying the condition of their ballclub is. and why should they know? neither of them has the faintest idea about how to evaluate anything related to baseball operations.

this writer would like to call the events of the last day a great step forward for accountability for this ballclub, to say that they gave rare credence to those who would argue that the management really do notice what happens on the field and take it seriously. but it seems that just the opposite is the deeper message of these events -- particularly in light of the continuing presence of the incompetent boob most responsible for the ridiculous state of the team, general manager jim hendry.

without question, macfail and baker were part of the problem at clark and addison. but what the events of the day have shown, dear reader, is that they are not so much the cause of the problems as symptoms of problems that clearly persist, as the promotion of mcdonough and continuation of hendry indicate. this is a happier day for cubdom, perhaps, for seeing the backs of these two -- but you'll pardon this page, dear reader, if it exhibits something less than exhiliration over what has happened. though glimpses of a new dawn are perhaps visible, a great deal more than this will need to transpire before anything like reason for optimism becomes here apparent.

Sunday, October 01, 2006

Dominoes start to fall: MacPhail Gone

The Chicago Cubs 2006 failure took it's first victim this afternoon. Surprisingly, the victim was not Dusty Baker. It was the leader of the whole brigade! Andy MacPhail has resigned as president of the Cubs. I repeat ANDY MACPHAIL HAS RESIGNED AS PRESIDENT OF THE CUBS.

John McDonough will serve as interim President of the Chicago Cubs. This quote from Dennis FitzSimons:

"John and Jim Hendry have one mandate: To win a world championship for the incredibly loyal fans of the Chicago Cubs"


Curious that McDonough has the interim label. We will know more in the coming days. The good news is that we have the regime change this franchise desperately needed.



UPDATE: GROTA has put together transcripts of the press conferece at Clark and Addison this afternoon.

MSM sees the light!

photo from the Chicago Sun-Times
On the morning of Dusty Baker's last game as Chicago Cub manager it was very interesting to find this Rick Morrisey column in the Chicago Tribune. The first paragraph says it all:

While Tribune Co. chairman, president and chief executive officer Dennis FitzSimons runs around trying to keep all the plates spinning, the two luckiest guys in the world have to be Andy MacPhail and Jim Hendry.


Morrisey is the latest member in the MSM to call this thing the way many in the CBA have called it for weeks, months and in a few cases years. While Dusty Baker was a problem, he was only part of the problem. There are bigger issues further up the cub food chain.

On Wednesday of this week the Tribs baseball bigfoot Phil Rogers called out Andy MacPhail for having little focus on the Cubs on-field woes.

The Cubs are finishing up a horrific season, arguably their most disappointing since 1969. His boss, Tribune Co., is facing its own set of unpleasant issues. And because of the labor talks, MacPhail is being forced to take his eye off the ball--that is, the on-field product at Clark and Addison, as well as at every minor-league stadium where farm teams play.


I was waiting for Phil to mention the Race to Mackinac in this laundry list of Andy's distractions:

MacPhail's attention has been diverted for a variety of reasons since the day in 2002 he promoted Jim Hendry to general manager, delegating responsibility for the Cubs' manager and 40-man roster. As president, MacPhail dealt with Don Fehr, falling concrete, city officials and roof-toppers, all the while hoping that power pitching and an increased payroll would give the Cubs the consistent success they lacked in his first 10 years on the job.


And here's the kicker from Rogers:

The question is--how does MacPhail, a baseball man hired to build a strong organization from the ground up, continue to avoid accountability for an operation that--with the exception of September and October 2003--has borne very little fruit?


Earlier in the week Barry Rozner in the Daily Herald took this swipe at Jim Hendry:

The Hendry who first joined the Cubs 12 years ago would have been willing to listen to concepts like OPS and would admit his starting rotation needs a massive makeover.

Those two things should have happened last winter, and must happen this winter.


Of course compliments must go to the Daily Herald's Bruce Miles who was the first member of the MSM to write the story blogs have been writing for months. Miles also let the facts tell the story:

For the fifth time in the last 10 years, the Cubs will finish with more than 90 losses. For the past 12 years, the man at the helm of the good ship Cubby has been Andy MacPhail, brought in after the 1994 players strike to lend stability and sense to an organization beset by chaos and bad decision-making.

MacPhail, a third-generation baseball man, brought good bloodlines and a winning pedigree. As general manager of the Minnesota Twins, he won world championships in 1987 and 1991, although his critics up north point out that the key parts of the ’87 team were in place before MacPhail got the GM job.

Since MacPhail arrived in Chicago, the Cubs have compiled an overall record of 912-1,006 (.475 winning percentage).

After coming within five outs of the 2003 World Series, the Cubs finished third in 2004 and fourth in 2005. They’re currently sixth and last in the National League Central.

If the College of Coaches era is the most ridiculed period in modern team history, Cubs fans have every right to believe the MacPhail era is the most disappointing, based on the expectations MacPhail brought with him and the deep pockets of the team’s ownership, the Tribune Co.


And in a move that shocked me the Trib's Morrisey openly discusses the turmoil in Trib Tower:

This pathetic season truly has been a team effort, and how MacPhail and Hendry are able to keep their jobs can be explained only by the turmoil inside Tribune Co.

The right thing to do would be to clean house, but FitzSimons has bigger worries than a bumbling baseball operation. The newspaper industry is in decline, Tribune Co. stock has been in the dumper for a long time and FitzSimons has said a restructuring of the corporate giant is under way.


Wow! It looks like the the mystery has been solved. When Phil Rogers is calling you out there might be troubles. The word is out on the street that MacSweatervest has failed as team President. Well, there's no time like the present for the Tribsters to do something about what really ails the Cubs.